What’s at the heart of Mercedes’ recent gearbox trouble?

Mercedes has made important changes underneath the bodywork ahead of the Styrian Grand Prix, in a bid to alleviate the gearbox problems that marred their race last week at Red Bull Ring.

What’s at the heart of Mercedes’ recent gearbox trouble?
Listen to this article

With the gearbox issues having been traced back to a combination of electrical noise and vibrations caused by running over high kerbs, the team faced an intense week finding a way to prevent a repeat. For Friday practice, it moved and re-routed some of the associated sensors and wiring looms in and around the gearbox and ran a range of experiments to try to better understand what is happening.

It will not know for sure it is in the clear until Sunday – and rivals will be doing everything they can to try to push the Mercedes cars to break.

Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes F1 W11 EQ Performance

Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes F1 W11 EQ Performance

Photo by: Mark Sutton / Motorsport Images

Valtteri Bottas, Mercedes F1 W11 EQ Performance, leads Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes F1 W11 EQ Performance, and Charles Leclerc, Ferrari SF1000

Valtteri Bottas, Mercedes F1 W11 EQ Performance, leads Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes F1 W11 EQ Performance, and Charles Leclerc, Ferrari SF1000

Photo by: Charles Coates / Motorsport Images

Mercedes first encountered the gearbox problem during Friday free practice last week and by qualifying it knew it faced a battle to survive the race. This essentially put them in management mode pretty early on in the race, as sensors on the car started to ring alarm bells on the pitwall, in the garages and at mission control back at Brackley – firstly on Bottas’ car and then Hamilton’s.

Mercedes trackside engineering director, Andrew Shovlin, says that it’s an issue that’s “not manifesting itself as one thing,” and that “it’s basically a build-up of electrical noise that starts to interfere with the various systems”.

The description from Shovlin suggests this is a problem that builds over time, and that the violent nature of the kerbs are causing the wiring looms to degrade. This then triggers the electrical interference that affects the gearbox sensors.

Read Also:

As James Vowles, Mercedes strategy director, explained: “The Austrian circuit is very, very aggressive, especially with the kerbs. You have to use the kerbs in order to get the lap time out of it but those kerbs are also generating a lot of vibrations in the car and a lot of load in the car.”

But, from a technical standpoint, are the kerbs really the trigger point and could there be a further factor that has come into play?

If we rewind to a video that Mercedes put out when it launched this year's challenger, technical director James Allison said: “The rear suspension on this car is extremely adventurous, specifically on the lower rear wishbone, where we’ve put a new geometry in there, that gives us more aerodynamic opportunity and allows us to get more downforce on the car.”

Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes F1 W11

Lewis Hamilton, Mercedes F1 W11

Photo by: Andy Hone / Motorsport Images

This alteration by Mercedes has resulted in the lower wishbone being raised up off the floor, aligning it more effectively with the driveshaft fairing behind. More importantly, it clears room for better flow over that section of floor, where it has extended the ceiling height of the diffuser.

Raising the lower wishbone’s anchor point on the gearbox casing raises an interesting technical novelty that the team ran last season and appears to have tried to make further gains from this season too.

To understand how this can have a bearing, perhaps it’s worth remembering that Mercedes has what’s known as a cassette-style arrangement. This basically means that the casing and crash structure are separate entities to the gearbox itself.

Ferrari F2004 and Mercedes W04 gearboxes

Ferrari F2004 and Mercedes W04 gearboxes

Photo by: Giorgio Piola

This is not a new arrangement for the team – it’s been constantly evolving the concept since first introducing it back in 2013. Aldo Costa is given the credit, having been with Ferrari when the Italian outfit first introduced it back in 2004. The reasons for such a solution have evolved over the years, but one of the major reasons is that it allows the team to change the casing and crash structure without suffering a penalty for changing the gearbox.

It also allows the gearbox and casing to be tested independently of one another, in order to reduce development and manufacturing lead times. It means the team has a huge amount of flexibility in terms of setup and design. Mercedes took another leaf out of Ferrari’s book last season, as its gearbox casing featured a solution favoured by Ferrari in 2015 and 2016, but which it has since moved away from.

Ferrari SF15-T gearbox and exhausts design

Ferrari SF15-T gearbox and exhausts design

Photo by: Giorgio Piola

This extreme packaging solution saw Ferrari, and now Mercedes, use four mounting studs between the power unit and gearbox casing rather than six, in order to shape the casing so it can repackage the exhausts. The knock-on effect is that the surrounding bodywork can also be shrink-wrapped more tightly and an aerodynamic advantage be gained.

These gains don’t come for free though, and mean that the casing must be pushed even closer to its structural limits, as it is missing the middle studs that would ordinarily help with the stress and torsional loads that it must endure. 

The following illustration of Mercedes 2014 power unit shows where the studs would ordinarily be placed, with the middle ones (blue arrow, below left) removed to make way for the repackaging of the more expansive exhaust solution now favoured (2019’s arrangement on the Racing Point RP19, below right).

Mercedes PU106 powerunit, pipework from compressor at the front of the ICE suggests Williams FW36

Mercedes PU106 powerunit, pipework from compressor at the front of the ICE suggests Williams FW36

Photo by: Giorgio Piola

Lance Stroll, Racing Point RP19, returns to the pits without an engine cover

Lance Stroll, Racing Point RP19, returns to the pits without an engine cover

Photo by: Mark Sutton / Motorsport Images

Interestingly, the FIA has recently moved to remove some ambiguity in the wording of the regulations surrounding this for 2021, making it obvious that four or six studs may be used, where it previously appeared that you must have six.

For those wondering why Racing Point didn’t suffer the same fate during the first race of the season, it’s likely due to the fact that while it buys some of its components from Mercedes, it still produces some of its own. In keeping with its quest to mimic last year’s Mercedes, the RP20 follows the same path as the W10 when it comes to its rear suspension geometry, with the wishbone mounted at a different angle to the W11.

Sergio Perez, Racing Point RP20

Sergio Perez, Racing Point RP20

Photo by: Mark Sutton / Motorsport Images

Triple whammy

Combining these two technical novelties on the W11, you’ll see that the lower wishbone is now fixed to the gearbox casing in a higher position and at a point further from the lower fixing studs. 

Sparks from the rear of Valtteri Bottas, Mercedes F1 W11 EQ Performance

Sparks from the rear of Valtteri Bottas, Mercedes F1 W11 EQ Performance

Photo by: Charles Coates / Motorsport Images

Having altered the load paths, this change, along with the shockwaves put through the car by the kerbs around the Red Bull Ring, could be contributing to the resonance issue that has a harmonic effect on the car's sensors and electrical components and can ultimately affect the operation of the gearbox.

shares
comments

Related video

Revealed: How Red Bull added flavour to its F1 rear wing
Previous article

Revealed: How Red Bull added flavour to its F1 rear wing

Next article

Ricciardo hit knee against steering column in FP2 crash

Ricciardo hit knee against steering column in FP2 crash
Why Mercedes believes it can make the step F1 needs to fight Red Bull Prime

Why Mercedes believes it can make the step F1 needs to fight Red Bull

The 2022 Formula 1 season was Mercedes' leanest for a decade, achieving just a solitary pole and grand prix win. Yet the team is confident it has got the tools it needs to cast that disappointment aside and return to the front of the field again next year.

How BRM's one-off F1 double defied its rollercoaster history Prime

How BRM's one-off F1 double defied its rollercoaster history

It’s 60 years since BRM achieved its goal and Graham Hill led the team to a world title double. But that was just part of the remarkable story of a unique team that at times overstretched its resources and had its fair share of disappointments.

Formula 1
Dec 8, 2022
The bold F1 DRS experiment that could end the debate forever Prime

The bold F1 DRS experiment that could end the debate forever

OPINION: The effectiveness of DRS in Formula 1 remains a topic of debate as the winter break gives a chance for reflection on the racing we saw in 2022. For all of its detractors, perhaps an experiment where DRS is cast aside and the impact this has on racing is in order to truly understand its merits in modern F1.

Formula 1
Dec 8, 2022
The sliding doors moment that saved Red Bull and Porsche Prime

The sliding doors moment that saved Red Bull and Porsche

OPINION: Everything looked set for Red Bull and Porsche to join forces for the 2026 season, before the marriage between both parties was called off. While at the time it looked like a major coup for Formula 1 in gaining both VW Group powerhouses Audi and Porsche for 2026, Red Bull and Porsche have really been spared a potentially fractious relationship.

Formula 1
Dec 7, 2022
How Tyrrell’s post-Stewart era descended into a fight to survive Prime

How Tyrrell’s post-Stewart era descended into a fight to survive

Glory days for Tyrrell became increasingly infrequent
 after Jackie Stewart’s retirement. But in the latest instalment of his history of the team for Autosport's sister title GP Racing, 
MAURICE HAMILTON recalls how Ken Tyrrell’s plucky and defiantly small team stayed bold enough to innovate – springing a surprise with F1’s first six-wheeled car

Formula 1
Dec 6, 2022
How departing F1 boss Brawn views F1’s new rules - and the future Prime

How departing F1 boss Brawn views F1’s new rules - and the future

Multiple-title-winning designer and team boss Ross Brawn is finally leaving Formula 1 after nearly 50 years in motorsport. But he still has plenty of insights on what’s working and what comes next, as he revealed to Motorsport.com in a far-reaching exclusive interview in Abu Dhabi.

Formula 1
Dec 2, 2022
The key F1 management call Ferrari must make to avoid more defeat Prime

The key F1 management call Ferrari must make to avoid more defeat

OPINION: Mattia Binotto’s departure from Ferrari will naturally bring a range of changes across the Formula 1 team. But how the changes shape up and the impact they could have is set to be dictated by a key direction Ferrari’s top dogs will need to pick

Formula 1
Nov 30, 2022
The difference between Mercedes’ stumble and the fall of F1 giants Prime

The difference between Mercedes’ stumble and the fall of F1 giants

OPINION: Mercedes endured its worst season of the hybrid Formula 1 era, but was mercifully spared its first winless campaign in over a decade late on. It has owned up to the mistakes it made which led to its troubled W13. And while its task to return to title-challenging contention is not small, its 2022 season seems more like a blip than the beginning of a downward spiral.

Formula 1
Nov 29, 2022