Why Tsunoda wasn’t at fault in Mexico F1 qualifying controversy

Yuki Tsunoda inadvertently found himself the villain in the eyes of many after qualifying for Formula 1’s Mexico City GP.

Why Tsunoda wasn’t at fault in Mexico F1 qualifying controversy

The AlphaTauri driver was deemed to have ruined the crucial final qualifying laps of both drivers from the sister Red Bull Racing team, and as such had the massed ranks of Sergio Perez and Max Verstappen fans on his case.

But what actually happened in those final moments of qualifying, and was the Japanese driver really at fault?

In fact it was an unusual set of circumstances. While it often happens at other stages of qualifying, it's rare for a driver to be on a slow in-lap right at the end of Q3, when everyone else is going flat out on what is supposed to be their fastest lap of the weekend.

And that was down to the strategy adopted by the AlphaTauri team. Tsunoda had a back of the grid power unit change penalty, and thus he went into qualifying with two targets – finish ahead of the three other drivers carrying similar penalties and thus claim 17th on the grid, and help his teammate Pierre Gasly with a tow.

As penalties have mounted up in recent races we've seen a few similar situations, but usually the towing only goes as far as Q2, because penalised drivers don't want to reach Q3 and be committed to starting on the "wrong" tyre from the back of the grid.

This time around two of the penalised guys did make it out of Q2. Lando Norris managed to do it on the favoured medium tyre and thus didn't make any compromises, but Tsunoda had to use the soft, thus committing himself to using a tyre at the start that everyone else tried hard to avoid.

The upside for his team was that Gasly would have a tow for the crucial final run in Q3, and that's what it worked towards.

The strategy meant that once he'd done his job and pulled Gasly down the straight Tsunoda would have to tour round knowing that a lot of fast cars would be coming up behind him on their final hot laps. In the event those he would have to let by were both Ferraris, both Red Bulls and both Mercedes.

Yuki Tsunoda, AlphaTauri

Yuki Tsunoda, AlphaTauri

Photo by: Mark Sutton / Motorsport Images

Here's a timeline of the radio traffic between Tsunoda and his engineer Mattia Spini at the end of Q3 as he approached the end of the preparation lap, and tried to make a gap between himself and Daniel Ricciardo up ahead.

Team: "Keep the position, it's good, stay there."

TSU: "I'm giving the pressure to Ricciardo."

Team: "You're doing very well, so it's all fine."

Tsunoda then dropped back slightly from Ricciardo as he reached the stadium section, while Gasly got into position behind, ready to get the tow.

Team: "OK, nobody pushing behind, so a nice time to open that gap. We have two seconds now. Six seconds now, we are good. Charge on and push."

Tsunoda then blasted down the straight with Gasly behind. At the end of it he jinked to the right and let the Frenchman through. He'd done what was asked, and moved aside like a pacemaker in a 1500m race.

Having slowed right down, Tsunoda then negotiated the Turn 1/2/3 complex, and headed down the straight to Turn 4. They key now was not to risk any penalty by impeding another driver.

Team: "OK, good job, Sainz is 12 behind."

He then crawled around Turns 4, 5 and 6.

Team: "Sainz seven behind, pushing. Stay negative."

He almost came a complete stop on the short straight that followed, so keen was he to stay well out of the way of the Ferrari driver.

That negative message was an important one – in effect it was a hurry up, Spini reminding him that he couldn't go too slowly, and had to keep up the required minimum speed for an in-lap.

Team: "And then we have Perez four behind, pushing. Pushing."

Tsunoda was now in the fast esses section, where it's all too easy to get in the way. To stay clear of Perez he briefly sped up and then drove straight onto the run-off area at Turn 10, in order to leave a clear track for the Red Bull driver. It's a standard move in such circumstances – but it threw up a massive cloud of dust.

Team: "Perez behind you. And Verstappen three behind. F***!"

It was at this point that Spini realised that Perez had gone off the road, joining Tsunoda in the run-off, and that both cars had then potentially interfered with the closely following Verstappen's lap.

After a pause Tsunoda said: "I mean I let him past really… I didn't do anything there."

Spini carried on monitoring approaching cars as his driver headed down the back straight towards the stadium.

Leclerc and Bottas swept by on the straight, and then after entering the stadium Tsunoda turned sharp left and cut across the tarmac infield, allowing Hamilton a clear run through the twisty bits. He then headed into the pits and came to a stop in the pitlane, where the radio chat continued.

"I couldn't do anything," he said. "Understand, you gave him space," said Spini. "You couldn't do anything more. Understood."

Then Spini added: "So Yuki, we are in front of Norris, and Gasly P5. So very nice job."

Spini may have tried hard to maintain a positive vibe, but the proverbial had already hit the fan as replays of the incident were shown, and a fruity radio message from Verstappen was played.

Having aborted his final lap and realised that his dream of starting from pole at his home race was gone Perez said nothing until he got back to the pitlane and stopped in parc ferme. His message was short but not sweet: "Ahhhh, f***'s sake."

On seeing the two cars off the road Verstappen had lifted briefly, expecting a yellow that never came.

In fact the marshals on the corner did a great job. They understood the significance of calling for a yellow with cars on their final laps, and instead they acted like a referee waving play on, and not whistling for a foul.

Verstappen soon realised that there was no yellow, but the damage to his lap was done even before he locked up at Turn 13 in the stadium. He then had a wobble onto the pit straight. After crossing the line he said, "Ah for f*** sake, what happened there in front of me?"

"Not quite sure," replied his engineer. "Slow button on, please Max. Tsunoda just, I dunno, parked it, so Checo had to back out."

"Unbelievable, such a dumb idiot," replied Verstappen.

Shortly afterwards in the press conference the Dutchman expanded on how things had unfolded.

"I don't know what happened in front of me, but it must have been Yuki holding up first Checo and then both of them, of course, had to go wide," he said.

"You arrive so quick it's difficult to pinpoint what's happening. I just saw a lot of dust, so I thought a car crashed and now with the yellow flag rules, I've been caught with that already here in Mexico, I backed out of it a bit.

"And then no yellow flag came so I continued pushing, but of course that's already like two-and-a-half tenths gone. So, my lap was basically finished."

His RBR team boss Christian Horner was quick to add his view.

"I think we got Tsunoda'd," he said. "Both drivers were up on their last lap. Max was up two-and-a-half tenths, I think Checo was just under two-tenths up.

"I don't understand why he was just cruising around at that part of the circuit. It's disappointing, because it affected both of the drivers because they're both pretty annoyed."

By now the momentum was building, and Tsunoda was widely seen to be at fault, although not all of those who rushed to judgement understood that he had driven off the road to get out of the way.

When he met the media immediately after qualifying, he still wasn't sure precisely what happened. However as the potential ramifications of having upset the Red Bull management became clear he looked like a deer caught in headlights.

"I didn't mess up the Red Bulls," he said. "Just a mistake by themselves. I don't know about Max? Did I hold up Max as well?"

Shown a video clip by a team member he said: "I went outside and I couldn't do anything more than that one. I mean, I don't know, where should I go there?

"If I had another chance I'd do the same thing. I don't know what should I do? Do you think I did wrong thing?"

Read Also:

Perez suggested that he'd gone off because he'd lost downforce due to Tsunoda being in front.

"Yuki was just ahead," he said. "I think I was a bit too close, and I lost a bit too much already, because we go through the high speed and it's pretty difficult through there when you have a close car ahead of you. And unfortunately I lost it there."

Given that Tsunoda was running slowly would the aero impact really have been that great? Or was it more a case that he was simply distracted momentarily by the huge cloud of dust thrown up by the AlphaTauri when it motored onto the run-off, something that the Japanese driver – trying to do the right thing – could not have foreseen?

Perez was right on the ragged edge, gunning for pole at his home race, with a car that frustratingly wasn't as good as it had been a few hours earlier when he topped FP3.

He was also forced to dig even deeper to try to match the surprising pace of Mercedes in qualifying. It wouldn't have taken very much to tip him over that edge, and send him off the road.

And don't forget how unusual it is for a driver to be running slowly at the end of Q3. Perez would not have been expecting to come across a slow moving car that was actively trying to stay out of his way, and he wasn't told by his team to watch out for a slow car. Like Verstappen, he saw the dust and assumed that there had been an incident.

In the end it was moot. While Horner noted that both drivers were up on their previous times before they came across Tsunoda, they were not going fast enough to have knocked Bottas and Hamilton off the front row, as Toto Wolff pointed out.

"I think at that stage, sector one and sector two, they were behind," he said. "I think it was something like two-tenths or two-and-a-half tenths."

The bottom line was it was just one of those things, and it was significant too that there wasn't even a hint of an FIA impeding investigation. A few seconds either way and Tsunoda would have been trundling down a straight when Perez and Verstappen passed by, and it wouldn't have been an issue.

It was an unfortunate co-incidence that the cars affected were the two Red Bulls. The incident made for some tension between the AlphaTauri and RBR camps, and it was clear that Franz Tost wasn't happy that his man had taken such a verbal beating from all sides.

"I absolutely don't understand why Perez went also off the track there," he said. "Yuki went to the side as all the drivers do in qualifying to make a place for the cars that are coming behind which are on a qualifying lap, he was not on a qualifying lap. It is as easy as that. Therefore I don't understand anything about this."

shares
comments

Related video

Horner wants to avoid ‘action replay’ of 2019 Mexico F1 clash
Previous article

Horner wants to avoid ‘action replay’ of 2019 Mexico F1 clash

Next article

Wolff yet to discuss F1 team orders with Mercedes drivers

Wolff yet to discuss F1 team orders with Mercedes drivers
Load comments
How getting sacked from Benetton made Mercedes' Allison Prime

How getting sacked from Benetton made Mercedes' Allison

He’s had a hand in world championship-winning Formula 1 cars for Benetton, Renault and Mercedes, and was also a cog in the Schumacher-Ferrari axis. Having recently ‘moved upstairs’ as Mercedes chief technical officer, James Allison tells Stuart Codling about his career path and why being axed by Benetton was one of the best things that ever happened to him.

Formula 1
Nov 28, 2021
The remarkable qualities that propelled Kubica’s F1 comeback Prime

The remarkable qualities that propelled Kubica’s F1 comeback

It’s easy to look at Robert Kubica’s second Formula 1 career and feel a sense of sadness that he didn’t reach the heights for which he seemed destined. But as Ben Anderson discovered, performance and results are almost meaningless in this context – something more fundamental and incredible happened…

Formula 1
Nov 27, 2021
The humbling changes Ricciardo made to deliver for McLaren Prime

The humbling changes Ricciardo made to deliver for McLaren

From being lapped by his own teammate in Monaco to winning at Monza, it’s been a tumultuous first season at McLaren for Daniel Ricciardo. But, as he tells STUART CODLING, there’s more to the story of his turnaround than having a lovely summer holiday during Formula 1's summer break...

Formula 1
Nov 26, 2021
The potential benefits of losing the F1 constructors' title Prime

The potential benefits of losing the F1 constructors' title

As the battle continues to rage over the F1 2021 drivers' championship, teams up and down the grid are turning their attentions to the prize money attributed to each position in the constructors' standings. But F1's sliding scale rules governing wind tunnel and CFD use will soften the blow for those who miss out on the top places

Formula 1
Nov 25, 2021
The invisible enemy that's made Hamilton's title charge tougher Prime

The invisible enemy that's made Hamilton's title charge tougher

After winning his past few Formula 1 titles as a canter, Lewis Hamilton currently trails Max Verstappen by eight points heading into the final double-header of 2021. Although Red Bull has been his biggest on-track challenge, Hamilton feels that he has just as much to grapple with away from the circuit

Formula 1
Nov 24, 2021
Why F1's inconvenient penalties have to stay Prime

Why F1's inconvenient penalties have to stay

OPINION: Quibbles over the length of time taken by Formula 1's stewards over decisions are entirely valid. But however inconvenient it is, there can be no questioning the importance of having clearly defined rules that everyone understands and can stick to. Recent events have shown that ambiguity could have big consequences

Formula 1
Nov 23, 2021
The mistakes Red Bull cannot afford to repeat in F1 2021's title fight climax Prime

The mistakes Red Bull cannot afford to repeat in F1 2021's title fight climax

OPINION: Red Bull has had Formula 1’s fastest package for most of 2021, but in several of the title run-in events it has wasted the RB16B’s potential. It cannot afford to do so again with Lewis Hamilton motoring back towards Max Verstappen in the drivers’ standings with two rounds remaining

Formula 1
Nov 23, 2021
Qatar Grand Prix driver ratings Prime

Qatar Grand Prix driver ratings

Qatar was a virtual unknown for most as Formula 1 made its inaugural visit to the Gulf state, and tyre management quickly emerged as an even more critical factor than normal. Perhaps then it should come as no surprise that two of the championship's elder statesmen produced standout drives

Formula 1
Nov 22, 2021