Vergne calls for changes to Formula E's identical duels time rule

Jean-Eric Vergne rued his elimination from the Berlin E-Prix duels after setting an identical laptime to semi-final opponent Alexander Sims, wanting a "fair" rules change if it happens again.

Vergne calls for changes to Formula E's identical duels time rule
Listen to this article

Sims had been up on Vergne in the opening pair of sectors, but Vergne pulled back enough time to ensure that when he crossed the line, the two were both left with a 1m06.050s time.

But as Sims had set his time first having kicked off their duel, he was allowed to progress into the final as Vergne was left to start fourth on the grid.

Directly after the session, Vergne stated that he was "pissed off" and that it was the "stupidest rule I have ever seen" as he was immediately drawn into a disadvantage.

Speaking to Motorsport.com later, the Frenchman stated that he still struggled to understand the rationale behind the rule.

"How can you be happy?" Vergne said.

"[The FIA needs to] make something to make something fair and smart. Like, the guy the fastest in the duels starts second because he was fastest?

"In that case, take the second fastest time in case it happens again. There were so many people, my friends watching, and nobody understood this rule, it's difficult to understand it."

Despite being the beneficiary of the rule, Sims agreed with Vergne's assessment and suggested that taking the fastest time from earlier in the duels would be a fairer way to separate any future identical times.

"I mean, honestly, when I did the same time I jokingly said, 'Well, I did the time first'," said the Briton. "I assume that's what the rule came down to.

"I think it would be fairer if it is the previous duels' fastest time, so then then the person that was faster in the previous duel would get through.

"Or in the first part in qualifying, I guess if happens in the qualifying session then it is probably the first driver who does it. But yeah, interesting situation."

Alexander Sims, Mahindra Racing, Mahindra M7Electro, Stoffel Vandoorne, Mercedes-Benz EQ, EQ Silver Arrow 02

Alexander Sims, Mahindra Racing, Mahindra M7Electro, Stoffel Vandoorne, Mercedes-Benz EQ, EQ Silver Arrow 02

Photo by: Simon Galloway / Motorsport Images

As a result, Sims progressed to the final where he was initially up on eventual polesitter and winner Edoardo Mortara before losing time in the final sector, but this still booked the Mahindra driver a place on the front row.

Although Sims dropped to ninth in the race, he still collected his first points of the season - but said that the comparative lack of race pace was a "reality of where I'm at" having struggled so far throughout the year.

Sims only progressed though to the duels when Nissan's Sebastien Buemi lost his best laptime for going below the minimum pitstop time.

"Since the first laps this morning, I've been fairly comfortable with the car," said Sims.

"We focused mainly on 220kW laps [in practice] so then to make it through to the duels was a good thing - obviously, a little bit fortuitously in the end with Buemi dropping out.

"But we had our own problems, that meant we weren't as fast as we really should have been, both Ollie [Rowland] and I.

"I think we should have actually got through on pace to the duels, then the other 250kW laps all went very nicely. In the end, it was a shame we weren't on pole, until that last sector.

"The race was probably just a bit of a reality of where I'm at, at the moment, having not had very good races up to now.

"We just lacked a little bit of pace and with the way that the race was fully green today, this circuit is all about efficiency. And we just lacked a little bit to be honest.

"It didn't seem horrendous, I could hang on for a while, but the good guys came through and I couldn't hold them back much longer after about halfway."

shares
comments
Berlin E-Prix: Mortara holds off late Vergne charge to win
Previous article

Berlin E-Prix: Mortara holds off late Vergne charge to win

Next article

Mortara: Road to Berlin E-Prix win was "long and stressful"

Mortara: Road to Berlin E-Prix win was "long and stressful"
How Jaguar got its teeth into Formula E's Gen3 development race Prime

How Jaguar got its teeth into Formula E's Gen3 development race

With Mercedes gone and DS moving teams, Jaguar has a big opportunity at the start of Formula E's Gen3 era. The technical challenges in understanding the new car have been vast, with senior figures James Barclay and Phil Charles outlining to Motorsport.com the pitfalls along the way

Formula E
Dec 1, 2022
The trait Vandoorne rediscovered to claim Formula E's era-ending title Prime

The trait Vandoorne rediscovered to claim Formula E's era-ending title

After Nyck de Vries was crowned Formula E champion in 2021, his Mercedes teammate Stoffel Vandoorne stepped forward this season as the Gen2 era and his team bowed out. As he did on the way to the GP2 crown in 2015, the Belgian achieved a peerless level of consistency and was only outside the points once, with his sole win in Monaco sufficient to head off a chasing pack headed by Mitch Evans

Formula E
Sep 19, 2022
Why Bird can bounce back after a tough 2021-22 Formula E season Prime

Why Bird can bounce back after a tough 2021-22 Formula E season

With his winning streak coming to an end this season, the 2021-22 Formula E season was tumultuous for Sam Bird, failing to gather momentum as Jaguar generally struggled. But the long-term favourite looks forward to bouncing back next season as the championship enters its new era

Formula E
Aug 30, 2022
What Formula E needs next after saying goodbye to Gen2 Prime

What Formula E needs next after saying goodbye to Gen2

The 2021-2022 Formula E season finale brought the curtain down on the Gen2 era of the all-electric world championship. It elevated FE to new heights, fulfilling its intended directive. While it is a good launching pad for the impending Gen3 cycle, there are certain aspects the series must tackle for the new era to have the same impact as its predecessor

Formula E
Aug 16, 2022
The traits behind Vandoorne's triumphant Formula E title charge Prime

The traits behind Vandoorne's triumphant Formula E title charge

The odds were heavily stacked in Stoffel Vandoorne’s favour to capture the Formula E crown at the Seoul finale, but chief rival Mitch Evans applied maximum pressure with victory in the first race. It meant Vandoorne had to show his resolve to reproduce the key qualities he held all season to complete his march to the title

Formula E
Aug 15, 2022
Can anyone beat Stoffel Vandoorne to the Formula E title? Prime

Can anyone beat Stoffel Vandoorne to the Formula E title?

Stoffel Vandoorne is on the brink of the Formula E title with a commanding lead ahead of the Seoul finale, but both rivals and unknowns still stand in his way. Here’s a run through of what Vandoorne must overcome to clinch the championship and how his competition will look to pull off the biggest of shocks.

Formula E
Aug 10, 2022
How Formula E's most underrated driver is taming his Dragon Prime

How Formula E's most underrated driver is taming his Dragon

It might not look like the most glittering of Formula E campaigns, but Dragon Penske’s youngster has caught the eye of those who count despite his future remaining unclear. Regardless of the distortion, Sergio Sette Camara has a clear vision of what he’s focused on and how to get there.

Formula E
Aug 4, 2022
How Formula E's title contenders were upstaged in London Prime

How Formula E's title contenders were upstaged in London

The penultimate stop on Formula E's world tour took in London's ExCeL, where the championship contenders were upstaged by two first-time winners in 2022. Andretti’s Jake Dennis kept the home fires burning in the first race as Venturi’s Lucas di Grassi claimed the second, but two consistent finishes mean its advantage Stoffel Vandoorne heading to the Seoul finale.

Formula E
Aug 1, 2022