What Honda still has to prove in IndyCar

With victory in the Indianapolis 500 achieved, it’s now time for Honda Performance Development's latest-spec engine to prove its mettle across all types of racetrack in the Verizon IndyCar Series, says David Malsher.

What Honda still has to prove in IndyCar
Alexander Rossi, Herta - Andretti Autosport Honda race winner
honda logo
James Hinchcliffe, Schmidt Peterson Motorsports Honda
Race winner Alexander Rossi, Herta - Andretti Autosport Honda
Race start
Race winner Carlos Munoz, Andretti Autosport Honda
Start: Helio Castroneves, Team Penske Chevrolet leads
A Honda engine
Marco Andretti, Andretti Autosport Honda
Honda Racing HPD engine
Honda aero parts detail
James Hinchcliffe, Schmidt Peterson Motorsports Honda
Honda Racing HPD signage
Marco Andretti, Andretti Autosport Honda
James Hinchcliffe, Schmidt Peterson Motorsports Honda
Mikhail Aleshin, Schmidt Peterson Motorsports Honda
Graham Rahal, Rahal Letterman Lanigan Racing Honda
Graham Rahal, Rahal Letterman Lanigan Racing Honda
Starting grid

So now we know: Honda’s pace at Indianapolis Motor Speedway was genuine. Its teams’ paranoia over what Chevrolet might have in reserve was unnecessary.The eventually wearisome persecution complex over domed skids was unfounded.

And those of us who thought HPD could only win Indy in fortuitous circumstances were hugely wide of the mark.

So hang out the bunting, wave your giant ‘H’ flags and erect a statue of Art St. Cyr (HPD prez) in Torrance, Calif.

Does this mean that Honda-powered teams can be expected to compete without disadvantage on all types of track now? That’s the multi-million dollar question as we head straight into Motown’s double-header.

Ever since Chevrolet returned to IndyCar following the introduction of the 2.2-liter direct injection turbo V6 rules in 2012, the engine settings for ovals and for road/street courses have been roughly 100-120hp apart.

Back in ’12, the figures were roughly 550hp oval, 670 road/street, but as Chevrolet and Honda have improved their breed and become ever more confident of making these engines last the requisite 2500 miles, those numbers have risen.

Motorsport.com sources suggest these figures have risen to 620 and 720, plus or minus 10hp. For that alone, both manufacturers should be commended: that’s a hell of a jump in just four years of competition.

However, it wasn’t until Indy that HPD released its definitive 2016 spec unit, when all teams are granted a “free” engine change for the 500.

And incidentally, it’s understood that the similar but hitherto unspecified failures suffered by Mikhail Aleshin’s Schmidt Peterson Motorsports car and Ryan Hunter-Reay’s Andretti Autosport entry during practice at Indy, came while using several of the new engine’s parts but not using the definitive latest-spec engines per se.

All it meant was that Aleshin and Hunter-Reay simply received their free engine change a couple of days early.

So the definitive 2016-spec HPD engine has covered itself literally and figuratively in glory. Given that the quirks and nuances of racing can sometimes twist perceived reality, HPD’s 1-3-4-5 on the Indy grid was even more significant than its 1-2 finish on raceday.

Hinchcliffe’s pole position was Honda’s first in the IndyCar Series since Houston in 2014.

Changing figures at the top

This weekend at the two races comprising the Chevrolet Dual in Detroit, we’re set to find out how well HPD’s newest unit will work in road/street-course tune, which basically involves altering the inlet trumpets and cranking the turbo from 1.3- to 1.5-bar (1.65 with Push to Pass boost).

So far this year, Chevrolet has dominated qualifying and most race days, while Honda has flattered to deceive through practice sessions. It’s understood that Chevy retards its ignition during practice, losing up to two percent of its horsepower, and when that last bit of potential is unleashed, the Hondas have been left gasping.

So what has been that difference in power output? As you can imagine, one has to plow through a lot of ‘no comments’, ‘I don’t knows’ and ‘I could tell you but I’d have to kill yous’ before reaching anything resembling a definitive figure.

However, Motorsport.com has learned that in qualifying – the peak of disparity between Chevrolets and Hondas – the gap has hitherto been up to 32kW or 43hp.

Now you can see why Honda drivers were worried in the run up to the 500, even aside from the domed skids (non-) issue. Assuming that output differential is reduced proportionally to the tune of the car for an oval, that would have still left Honda 37hp short.

Up in the 220mph-plus range, every 7hp equates to 1mph around the Speedway, Honda cars would have been approximately 5mph slower than they were. Cut polesitter James Hinchcliffe’s lap speeds by 5mph and he would have scarcely outqualified two Chevy-powered cars.  

What a drag

It’s not that simple though, because there’s an additional factor to be considered here, too: the drag of the aerokit.

If you find it hard to imagine that HPD has recouped its serious power deficit to Chevrolet in one hit, you can only conclude that the manufacturers’ very comparable speeds at Indy mean that the HPD/Honda Japan-produced aerokit for this year is exceptionally slippery in superspeedway form.

This is interesting, because that validates IndyCar’s decision in the off-season when implementing Rule 9.3. The governing body decreed HPD did not need help with its superspeedway kit and instead allowed Honda to catch up with Chevrolet in terms of its drag/downforce equation only for road/street/short-ovals.

Ironically, that’s where some say Honda is lagging badly, but the emphasis there is on the word “some”. Back in Phoenix, running the short-oval kit, personnel from Honda-powered teams were completely at odds as to why the top Honda in qualifying was 3.2mph slower than the top Chevy over two 1-mile laps.

One Honda team owner muttered, “Is it just me or are Honda even further behind than last year with their aerokit? It’s just so draggy.” Yet the lead Honda driver on that occasion, Marco Andretti, disagreed entirely. “It’s a power issue,” he said firmly, “we’re just way off. We’re fastest Honda and we’re 11th fastest.”

Last month, in his column for Motorsport.com, Marco expanded on his comment, pointing out the knock-on effect.

Describing the race, he said the Chevy cars “got great fuel mileage because they were able to lift going into corners because their power was keeping them out of our range. I’d be following a Chevy, I’d see the flame out the back as the driver was rolling off the throttle into the corner, and I’d still be hard on the gas but when we came out of the turn I hadn’t gained anything from the previous straight.”

Question marks and anomalies

There were similar comments at Long Beach, where Chevrolet locked out the Firestone Fast Six (despite promising practice form from Hinchcliffe and Graham Rahal) and after the race several Honda drivers commented they couldn’t keep up with Chevy drivers out of the slowest turns.

But how representative was that race when everyone’s pace was controlled by a ridiculous fuel-mileage number? The different corner-exit speeds were as likely to be a result of alternative fuel-save techniques as they were power characteristics.

Here's an apparent anomaly, though. How come someone who’s 40hp down can qualify in the top six at Barber Motorsports Park and fight for the win? Was Graham Rahal’s set-up so good that he was really carrying that much more speed through the corners than top Chevy drivers and all other HPD-powered drivers? It seems unlikely… although there is a caveat to that.

“The Hondas do have more drag than us, I think,” said one Chevy driver about a month ago, “but they also have 200lbs more downforce toward the front. They turn on their tires [raise them to operating temperature] quicker than we do, which is what you want for qualifying, and that balance also helps in the race because you get less understeer and don’t wear out the front tires so quick.

“Basically, until Chevy turns up our engines for qualifying, I’d say the two manufacturers have looked about equal overall. So if Honda got their engines matching ours, we’d have a fight.”

And that may be exactly what’s happened, judging by the manufacturers’ relative Indy 500 performances. If HPD’s engine improvements really do translate to the higher power engine settings of the road/street courses, Chevrolet may get beaten up in its own backyard this weekend.

At the very least, we should soon know a lot more… 

Pigot joins Ed Carpenter Racing for road and street courses
Previous article

Pigot joins Ed Carpenter Racing for road and street courses

Next article

Power dominates first practice at Detroit

Power dominates first practice at Detroit
Load comments
Ranking the top 10 IndyCar drivers of 2021 Prime

Ranking the top 10 IndyCar drivers of 2021

In an enthralling 2021 IndyCar campaign, the series bounced back from its COVID-19 truncated year prior and series sophomore Alex Palou defeated both the established order and his fellow young guns to clinch a maiden title. It capped a remarkable season with plenty of standout performers

Nov 22, 2021
How Marcus Ericsson finally unlocked his potential in IndyCar Prime

How Marcus Ericsson finally unlocked his potential in IndyCar

Marcus Ericsson enjoyed a breakout year in the IndyCar Series in 2021, winning twice and finishing sixth in points with Chip Ganassi Racing. How did he finally unlock the potential that was masked by five years of toil in Formula 1 with Caterham and Sauber/Alfa Romeo?

Nov 16, 2021
Remembering Dan Wheldon and his last and most amazing win Prime

Remembering Dan Wheldon and his last and most amazing win

Saturday, Oct. 16th, marks the 10th anniversary Dan Wheldon’s death. David Malsher-Lopez pays tribute, then asks Wheldon’s race engineer from 2011, Todd Malloy, to recall that magical second victory at the Indianapolis 500.

Oct 16, 2021
Have Harvey and RLL formed IndyCar’s next winning match-up? Prime

Have Harvey and RLL formed IndyCar’s next winning match-up?

Jack Harvey’s move to Rahal Letterman Lanigan Racing sparked plenty of debate, but their combined strength could prove golden, says David Malsher-Lopez.

Oct 15, 2021
Why Kyle Kirkwood is America's new IndyCar ace-in-waiting Prime

Why Kyle Kirkwood is America's new IndyCar ace-in-waiting

Kyle Kirkwood, the record-setting junior formula driver, sealed the Indy Lights championship last weekend. But despite an absurdly strong résumé and scholarship money, his next move is far from clear. By David Malsher-Lopez.

Oct 6, 2021
2021 IndyCar title is just the start for Ganassi's newest star Prime

2021 IndyCar title is just the start for Ganassi's newest star

Alex Palou has captured Chip Ganassi Racing's 14th IndyCar drivers' championship, and in truly stellar manner. David Malsher-Lopez explains what made the Palou-Ganassi combo so potent so soon.

Sep 28, 2021
Why Grosjean's oval commitment shows he's serious about IndyCar Prime

Why Grosjean's oval commitment shows he's serious about IndyCar

One of motorsport’s worst-kept secrets now out in the open, and Romain Grosjean has been confirmed as an Andretti Autosport IndyCar driver in 2022. It marks a remarkable turnaround after the abrupt end to his Formula 1 career, and is a firm indication of his commitment to challenge for the IndyCar Series title  

Sep 24, 2021
IndyCar’s longest silly-season is still at fever pitch Prime

IndyCar’s longest silly-season is still at fever pitch

The 2021 IndyCar silly season is one of the silliest of all, but it’s satisfying to see so many talented drivers in play – including Callum Ilott. David Malsher-Lopez reports.

Sep 11, 2021