F1 engineers discuss the Ducati MotoGP aero dispute

The controversial winglet ran by Ducati's Andrea Dovizioso on his way to victory in the MotoGP season-opening Qatar Grand Prix generates downforce, according to Formula 1 engineers.

F1 engineers discuss the Ducati MotoGP aero dispute

Honda, Aprilia, Suzuki and KTM lodged a complaint against Ducati over the legality of the winglet, which the Italian manufacturer attached to the swingarm of its bike, claiming it is used to cool down the rear tyre.

While stewards in Qatar threw out the protest, the case was referred to the FIM Court of Appeals and a decision is expected before the next race in Argentina.

Ducati's rivals believe the primary purpose of the winglet is to generate additional downforce.

Earlier this year, MotoGP technical director Danny Aldridge sent a note to all teams, opening the door for such add-ons to be used in dry races, as previously such a deflector could only be used in the wet to disperse water from around the tyre.

Motorsport.com asked ex-Formula 1 engineers to analyse the Ducati winglet and they believe there is no doubt the winglet creates aerodynamic load.

Ex-Ferrari F1 engineer Toni Cuquerella told Motorsport.com: "It's obvious that Ducati's winglet generates downforce. First of all, because any part that's exposed the way that one is produces it, and it could even help reduce the bike's drag.

"You have to keep in mind also that the effect it creates has a direct impact on the rear end. Since it's attached to the swingarm, the airflow must not be passing though any other part of the bike.

"The problem is that the way the rules are written, you open a Pandora's box because there might be no specific way to ban it."

Cuquerella, now chief engineer of the Mahindra Formula E team, added: "The FIM now faces the need to clarify the situation. It appears obvious that Ducati is ahead of the rest in terms of aerodynamics, and that they were very smart in how they interpreted a void in the rules."

A McLaren F1 team-employed aero expert who preferred to remain anonymous agreed with Cuquerella's view.

"It's obvious that the device generates downforce. Probably less than the winglets on the fairing, but of course it generates downforce," the British team's engineer said.

The fact that the stewards in charge of reviewing the protest filed by Aprilia, Suzuki, Honda and KTM decided to refer the case to the MotoGP Court of Appeals was the first sign of the mess that was knocking on the ruling body's door.

"In F1, aerodynamics have had a major impact on the performance of the cars for the past 30 years. In motorcycling, the impact is smaller, so it's normal that FIM is not used to dealing with this kind of cheekiness," said Cuquerella.

"But even in F1 there have recently been cases where a loophole in the regulations allowed a smart team to interpret the rules in such a way that it managed to use something that it was initially banned. We can't forget Brawn GP's double diffuser and Red Bull's blown diffuser."

Last summer, the Grand Prix commission approved a rule - voted against by Ducati - that aimed to stop the teams' from investing in aerodynamics development, in order to slow down the escalating costs associated with it.

However, the fact that Ducati's winglet is attached to the swingarm and is not recognised by the regulations as a part of the bike's aero body, opened the door for the Italian engineers to introduce the device without breaking the rules.

Cuquerella concluded: "When Ducati told MotoGP technical director Danny Aldridge that the main function of the device was not to direct water away from the wheel but to cool the rear tyre down, they managed to get it approved for dry races.

"The FIM will have to rewrite the technical regulations, because what's obvious is that it won't be able to take the bikes, one by one, and put them in a wind tunnel to quantify the amount of downforce that each part generates.

"You can't ban parts that generate downforce if you can't prove that they are generating it. What you can do is specify some dimensions in the rules."

Ducati remains confident that the device is within the regulations and says it would not have installed it had it had any doubts about its legality.

"We are calm because we know that we have followed the technical regulations," sporting director Paolo Ciabatti told Motorsport.com in Qatar.

"There is a note that was distributed among the teams on March 2, which clearly specified how you could use this type of deflector on the back of the bike.

"If we had considered that this element could pose a risk of punishment, we would not have run with it. But it's not like that."

shares
comments
Ducati threatens Honda protest as winglet row escalates

Previous article

Ducati threatens Honda protest as winglet row escalates

Next article

Marquez: Honda couldn't tolerate Ducati speed deficit

Marquez: Honda couldn't tolerate Ducati speed deficit
Load comments
Why Marc Marquez has to reinvent himself as a MotoGP rider Prime

Why Marc Marquez has to reinvent himself as a MotoGP rider

Marc Marquez's romp to victory at the Grand Prix of the Americas led many to believe the 'old' pre-injury Honda rider was close to coming back to his full powers. However, the 'old' Marquez will probably never exist again and instead he'll have to adapt to his new reality to return to title-winning ways in 2022.

MotoGP
Oct 6, 2021
Why self-preservation was key to Marquez's COTA "dream" result Prime

Why self-preservation was key to Marquez's COTA "dream" result

Marc Marquez scorched to his seventh Circuit of the Americas victory in MotoGP last Sunday with a display reminiscent of his pre-injury form. However, his path to the win across the weekend was in keeping with the current reality of his physical limitations, with self-preservation on Saturday key to his Sunday success

MotoGP
Oct 4, 2021
How Ducati has developed MotoGP's most versatile bike Prime

How Ducati has developed MotoGP's most versatile bike

His third place at Misano made Enea Bastianini the fifth different Ducati-mounted rider to score a podium in 2021. Amid a season that has seen one rider amass the bulk of Yamaha and Honda's success, the Ducati's versatility makes for a potent weapon, but the contribution of a former leading light shouldn't be forgotten

MotoGP
Sep 23, 2021
The next steps in the rebuilding of a stalled MotoGP career Prime

The next steps in the rebuilding of a stalled MotoGP career

Maverick Vinales’ early debut with Aprilia has been one of the most interesting plots of the recent MotoGP rounds. The results may not look standout on paper, but a closer inspection reveals just how much progress Vinales has truly made in understanding a bike that has taken him well out of his “comfort zone”.

MotoGP
Sep 22, 2021
Why Misano was a pivotal race for MotoGP's present and future Prime

Why Misano was a pivotal race for MotoGP's present and future

On a day each of the podium trio could claim to be the star of the show, the San Marino GP will be remembered as a pivotal race in both MotoGP's present and future. While Fabio Quartararo demonstrated his world title credentials just behind Francesco Bagnaia's flawless victory charge, a new threat emerged from the shadows

MotoGP
Sep 20, 2021
How Ducati's Aragon MotoGP win harks to its past and its future Prime

How Ducati's Aragon MotoGP win harks to its past and its future

Duelling against Marc Marquez at the Aragon Grand Prix, Francesco Bagnaia came out on top to secure a long overdue MotoGP victory. As Marquez likened Bagnaia to a Ducati title contender of old, it appears the Italian rider could finally start to fight for wins on a more regular basis

MotoGP
Sep 13, 2021
Why Dovizioso is more of a temporary fix than a Yamaha gamble Prime

Why Dovizioso is more of a temporary fix than a Yamaha gamble

OPINION: The return of Andrea Dovizioso to the grid at Misano will be an interesting subplot to the remainder of the 2021 MotoGP season. But the circumstances that have led to the former Ducati rider ending his sabbatical point to his signing being one more of convenience than a long-term commitment

MotoGP
Sep 8, 2021
Why the British GP was a triumph for MotoGP Prime

Why the British GP was a triumph for MotoGP

OPINION: The 2021 British Grand Prix was a historic day for MotoGP. At the centre of it was Aleix Espargaro on the Aprilia after securing its first podium in the modern MotoGP era. It was something of a full-circle moment that highlighted just how far MotoGP has come in the last decade

MotoGP
Aug 30, 2021