Dane: Drivers shouldn't make Supercars paddle shift call

Feedback from Supercars drivers shouldn't be the deciding factor in the paddles versus stick shift debate, according to outgoing Triple Eight boss Roland Dane.

Dane: Drivers shouldn't make Supercars paddle shift call

The Aussie category is currently weighing up both paddle and stick shift for its Gen3 cars, the matter having morphed into a flashpoint of controversy over the past year.

It was originally confirmed that an electronic Auto Gear Shift system would be introduced regardless, and then operated by either paddles or a stick, however it appears retaining the current mechanical stick shift is back on the table.

The issue has polarised the paddock, with drivers by and large in favour of keeping the stick and team owners split on the matter, some in favour of paddles and some against.

However that opinion from the drivers shouldn't carry decisive weight in the argument, says Dane, who wants to see he call made based on factors such as cost and entertainment.

"Almost all the drivers are paid, they’re not paying. So to be honest they’re not the ones who should be making the call," he told media during the Gen3 launch.

"The people who should be making the call are the team owners and television of Supercars, in trying to decide what’s the right path for the future for the next five, 10 years.

"The drivers, at the end of the day, are paid to do a job. I have never seen a Supercars driver turn down driving a good GT3 car, they’ve all got paddle shift.

"I haven’t even seen them turning down driving TCR cars. It’s not something they fundamentally hate so much that they won’t drive a car.

"I think it’s more about the fans, they television and the team owners and the costs associated that [Supercars CEO] Sean [Seamer] and his team need to take into account before they make a call.

"The call should be finally made by them. They’ve got inputs from teams and from television, and they’ve got to make a call and then everyone should live with it.

"The drivers have got views, some of which they air publicly and some of which they air privately. But at the end of the day the drivers are paid to do a job and they will drive whatever they are given."

Read Also:

Dane likened the debate to the category's move from a H-pattern gearbox to the stick-operated sequential system back in 2008, something he says the more experienced drivers in the field were opposed to.

"We had a debate about H-pattern versus sequential years ago," he said.

"The owners all wanted to have a sequential gearbox in the car because it was going to save money in terms of engines. The older drivers, they all wanted the H-pattern because they knew how to go from sixth to second and change hear coming down from Skyline and not lose the car... they had a vested interest.

"But we ended up with a sequential shift and the argument was forgotten six months later. We got on with life.

"This time a decision will be made, whichever way, and in a month or two everyone will just get on with it. Including drivers."

A decision is expected within the next fortnight before Gen3 prototype testing begins in earnest.

As it stands the Camaro prototype is fitted with AGS and paddles, while the Mustang is fitted with AGS, paddles and an electronic-controlled stick shift.

The Gen3 cars will continue to use the same Xrac transaxle that's fitted to the current-spec cars either way.

shares
comments
Post-Bathurst border relief for Supercars teams
Previous article

Post-Bathurst border relief for Supercars teams

Next article

Early Adelaide 500 revival on the table

Early Adelaide 500 revival on the table
Load comments
Why Courtney and Tickford are a dream match Prime

Why Courtney and Tickford are a dream match

James Courtney has been around the block in his motorsport career it's fair to say. After a single-seater career cut short, he's won everything there is to win in Supercars. Following a rocky ride recently in the Australian category, he's found a happy hunting ground with Tickford Racing.

Supercars
Oct 21, 2021
How taming his temper shaped Supercars' slow-burn star Prime

How taming his temper shaped Supercars' slow-burn star

His decision to leave Brad Jones Racing was the biggest shock of the Australian Supercars silly season so far. But for Nick Percat, it comes as the culmination of a personal journey that has made him into one of the most rounded drivers in the series, now in search of a seat that can make him a champion

Supercars
Sep 17, 2021
Why replacing Supercars' GOAT with a teenager is worth the risk for T8 Prime

Why replacing Supercars' GOAT with a teenager is worth the risk for T8

On the face of it, picking an 18-year-old rookie to replace arguably the greatest Supercars driver of all time is a risky move. But as Jamie Whincup takes up a team principal role and hands his car to Broc Feeney, it's one that he is confident will be rewarded in the fullness of time - time which wasn't afforded to Whincup in his early days

Supercars
Sep 1, 2021
How Randle went from fighting cancer to battling for Supercars contention Prime

How Randle went from fighting cancer to battling for Supercars contention

After his fledgling career was paused by a battle with testicular cancer, Thomas Randle then had to wrestle with finding a drive in Supercars after he got the all-clear. It's been a long road for the Melbourne native but, after two lengthy battles, he's finally got a full-time drive to look forward to

Supercars
Jun 29, 2021
How crisis talks over Supercars’ Gen3 future could leave it without a paddle Prime

How crisis talks over Supercars’ Gen3 future could leave it without a paddle

With Supercars’ Gen3 era on the horizon, a shift is set to take place – in more ways than one – but, as has become clear in recent weeks, the plan to bin the stick and use paddles with electronic assisted shift has been met with fierce opposition

Supercars
May 24, 2021
Can DJR still be a Supercars powerhouse after Penske? Prime

Can DJR still be a Supercars powerhouse after Penske?

Roger Penske's whirlwind Australian Supercars sojourn is over. After six seasons, three drivers' titles, three teams' championships and a Bathurst 1000 crown, The Captain has sold his controlling stake in Dick Johnson Racing back to the squad and walked away from the category.

Supercars
Feb 26, 2021
Can Whincup be Triple Eight's ruthless leader? Prime

Can Whincup be Triple Eight's ruthless leader?

Supercars' most successful team of the past 15 years is set for a radical shakeup next year when Jamie Whincup retires from driving and takes over the reins at Triple Eight. But does he have what it takes to be the new Roland Dane?

Supercars
Feb 8, 2021
How a lifetime Supercars deal broke down in one year Prime

How a lifetime Supercars deal broke down in one year

David Reynolds inked what was effectively a lifetime deal with Erebus in 2019 – only to walk out a year later. What went wrong?

Supercars
Dec 18, 2020