Analysis: When having the fastest car just isn’t good enough

Porsche 5-1 Audi. This year’s FIA World Endurance Championship looks like a drubbing, but in fact those statistics don’t reveal half the story. Charles Bradley tells you what else you need to know about Audi v Porsche in 2016.

Analysis: When having the fastest car just isn’t good enough
Anthony Davidson, Toyota Racing
#8 Audi Sport Team Joest Audi R18 e-tron quattro: Lucas di Grassi, Loic Duval, Oliver Jarvis, #5 Toyota Racing Toyota TS050 Hybrid: Sébastien Buemi, Kazuki Nakajima, Anthony Davidson
#8 Audi Sport Team Joest Audi R18 e-tron quattro: Lucas di Grassi, Loic Duval, Oliver Jarvis
Lucas di Grassi, Oliver Jarvis, Audi Sport Team Joest
#8 Audi Sport Team Joest Audi R18 e-tron quattro: Lucas di Grassi, Loic Duval, Oliver Jarvis
Podium: second place Lucas di Grassi, Loic Duval, Oliver Jarvis, Audi Sport Team Joest
Podium: race winner Mark Webber, Porsche Team
Podium: race winner Mark Webber, Porsche Team
Podium: race winners Timo Bernhard, Mark Webber, Brendon Hartley, Fritz Enzinger, Vice President LMP1, Porsche Team
Race winners #1 Porsche Team Porsche 919 Hybrid: Timo Bernhard, Mark Webber, Brendon Hartley
Fireworks at the Circuit of the Americas
#8 Audi Sport Team Joest Audi R18 e-tron quattro: Lucas di Grassi, Loic Duval, Oliver Jarvis
Race winners #1 Porsche Team Porsche 919 Hybrid: Timo Bernhard, Mark Webber, Brendon Hartley
Race winners #1 Porsche Team Porsche 919 Hybrid: Timo Bernhard, Mark Webber, Brendon Hartley, Fritz Enzinger, Vice President LMP1, Porsche Team, Magnus Walker
#8 Audi Sport Team Joest Audi R18 e-tron quattro: Lucas di Grassi, Loic Duval, Oliver Jarvis
#8 Audi Sport Team Joest Audi R18 e-tron quattro: Lucas di Grassi, Loic Duval, Oliver Jarvis
Race winners #1 Porsche Team Porsche 919 Hybrid: Timo Bernhard, Mark Webber, Brendon Hartley
#8 Audi Sport Team Joest Audi R18 e-tron quattro: Lucas di Grassi, Loic Duval, Oliver Jarvis
#8 Audi Sport Team Joest Audi R18 e-tron quattro: Lucas di Grassi, Loic Duval, Oliver Jarvis
Neel Jani, Porsche Team

“Why do you keep giving race wins away?” Toyota’s Anthony Davidson is in jocular mood as he verbally trolls Audi ambassador Allan McNish – a fellow former world champion – in the aftermath of the 6 Hours of COTA, the second FIA World Endurance Championship race in a row in which Porsche has snatched victory from Audi’s grasp.

“Why can’t you finish better than fifth?” the quick-witted McNish fires back, which receives a middle finger from the similarly-diminutive Englishman as he scuttles away. It’s the sort of banter that’s sorely missing from F1 – I can only recall the Lewis Hamilton/Sebastian Vettel 'seagull incident' in Montreal for any display of repartee this year.

But many true words are spoken in jest. The fact remains that Audi had the pace and ability to win the sixth round of the WEC, turning its qualifying front-row lockout into a dominant 1-2 until the sun went down.

The #8 R18 suffered an electrical shutdown in Loic Duval’s hands, and then the Audi’s requirement for an extra pitstop haunted it, as the longer-running Porsche was able to pit under full-course yellow as opposed to Audi’s enforced green-flag stop.

That put the #1 Porsche out front, where it stayed, as the #7 crashed giving frantic chase and the #8 could only recover to second after being forced to pit twice in two laps to have the driver’s door closed properly.

“The setbacks hit us hard” 

After the race, Audi was very honest in its admission that it only had itself to blame.

“It’s hard to believe how much can go wrong in the course of a six-hour race,” said Audi’s motorsport boss Dr Wolfgang Ullrich. “We were fast in all sessions and in the race nobody drove any faster lap times than us.

“The setbacks hit us hard because today a 1-2 would have been possible. In this light, second place is cold comfort.” 

Nowhere was that more apparent than at the entrance to the media centre after Saturday’s night’s race. My target was to get a Mark Webber one-on-one interview, before the press conference, and while he was buzzing over victory (as you can see in the video below), before he arrived Audi’s Lucas di Grassi and Oliver Jarvis trudged in.

Lucas muttered “I can’t believe we lost another win” – while Olly’s face was pure thunder as he stormed past with Audi’s communications queen Eva-Maria Vieth.

Why is Audi wobbling?

It’s been a true rollercoaster for Audi in WEC, with the normally unshakable Joest Racing squad wobbling off the tightrope more than once – perhaps a legacy of some staffing changes over the winter. At Silverstone, it shocked everyone with an on-the-road victory that was then swept away just about on the stroke of midnight by exclusion over its winning car’s rideheight being too low.

Then Audi inherited victory at Spa, a true race of attrition – but a deserved win, nonetheless. Le Mans was a disaster, by its lofty standards anyway, while Nurburgring, Mexico and now Austin have all gone the way of Porsche.

And yet, the R18 has been getting stronger and stronger. It is now a true match for Porsche’s 919 Hybrid on single-lap pace, and you can argue – when the car is within its tyre-performance window – it’s downright faster.

But Audi keeps tripping over its own feet in the races, and remains plagued by debris affecting its complex front aerodynamics and suspension systems, which makes it prone to ‘switching off’ its front tyres, causing massive understeer. It’s fast but still fragile – but that’s what you get when you opt for a radical design, which Audi gambled on.

The nature of these WEC LMP1 rocketships means that there’s quite some fluctuation from circuit to circuit – Toyota’s whole aero ethos is low-downforce, for example, which is why it flew at Le Mans but not at the Nurburgring.

Reigning champion Porsche has held the mantle of top all-round performer since last year’s Nurburgring race, but finally it’s being challenged for supremacy week-in, week-out.

So what happens next?

And after musing over the disappointment with McNish on Saturday night, talk quickly turned to optimism over what’s ahead. Sure, Toyota will be more of a threat in Fuji with its low-drag/strong mechanical grip setup, but Audi and Porsche should be closely matched once more there.

In the points tables, it’s that same old one-sided story: Porsche ahead by 53 in the manufacturers’ standings and the #2 squad 37.5s ahead of Audi's #8 – which lost a heap of ground in Mexico due to a wheel-bearing failure. When combined with Austin, that 5-1 winning scoreline could be 3-3 now.

Nobody at Audi is giving up the fight just yet. But while there are more battles to be fought, you can’t help thinking the #2 Porsche – with its inherited Silverstone victory and Le Mans 24 Hours double-points win – has already won the war.

Don't miss our Inside WEC report from COTA...

shares
comments
COTA keeps place on WEC 2017 schedule, FE clash still possible

Previous article

COTA keeps place on WEC 2017 schedule, FE clash still possible

Next article

BMW announces 2018 FIA WEC GTE programme

BMW announces 2018 FIA WEC GTE programme
Load comments
Why Toyota's Le Mans victory was not as simple as it looked Prime

Why Toyota's Le Mans victory was not as simple as it looked

Toyota scored its fourth Le Mans 24 Hours victory and a 1-2, with the #7 car of Kamui Kobayashi, Mike Conway and Jose Maria Lopez beating the #8. But although it looked straightforward from the outside, Toyota faced serious problem that had to be solved with some quick-thinking and ingenuity.

Le Mans
Aug 24, 2021
What we've learned from the Le Mans 24 Hours so far Prime

What we've learned from the Le Mans 24 Hours so far

The new dawn for the FIA World Endurance Championship has arrived at Le Mans, as Hypercars prepare to duel for victory in the world's oldest endurance race. Motorsport.com picks out the 10 things we have learned in the build up to the race.

Le Mans
Aug 21, 2021
Le Mans 2021: The team-by-team guide Prime

Le Mans 2021: The team-by-team guide

After a two-month delay due to the ongoing impact of the COVID-19 pandemic, the 2021 Le Mans 24 Hours is set to get underway with the start of the Hypercar era at the Circuit de la Sarthe.

Le Mans
Aug 21, 2021
Can Toyota's #7 crew break its Le Mans curse? Prime

Can Toyota's #7 crew break its Le Mans curse?

One Toyota, normally with the number 7 on the side, always seems to attract the bad luck in the Le Mans 24 Hours. Mike Conway, Kamui Kobayashi and Jose Maria Lopez are hoping for a change in fortune this time around, but face significantly more unknowns than in recent years

Le Mans
Aug 19, 2021
Why Glickenhaus should be taken seriously on its Le Mans bow Prime

Why Glickenhaus should be taken seriously on its Le Mans bow

Many were quick to dismiss Glickenhaus when the boutique American sportscar firm's entry into the top class of the Le Mans 24 Hours was announced. It's all-new LMH racer, powered by an engine built by a rally specialist, goes in as the underdog against Toyota but the mathematical odds suggest that it has more than just a faint hope of success.

Le Mans
Aug 18, 2021
How 1971's benchmark Le Mans team lost with the best car Prime

How 1971's benchmark Le Mans team lost with the best car

The JW Automotive Engineering team won twice at the Le Mans 24 Hours with ageing Fords and was considered the heavy favourite to add more victories to its tally after partnering with Porsche. But despite being armed with the all-conquering 917, this formidable combination was never as successful in real life as on the big screen.

Le Mans
Aug 15, 2021
Why Jose Maria Lopez isn’t motivated by emulating Fangio Prime

Why Jose Maria Lopez isn’t motivated by emulating Fangio

Having twice missed out on Formula 1 and reinvented himself as a touring car driver, Jose Maria Lopez has had a rocky ride to becoming a four-time world champion. One more would put him level with his nation's favourite son, but there's another prize he would value far more than the honour of matching Juan Manuel Fangio's tally.

WEC
Aug 14, 2021
The understated Le Mans legend who has earned a testimonial Prime

The understated Le Mans legend who has earned a testimonial

OPINION: After 24 Le Mans 24 Hours participations, 50-year-old Emmanuel Collard will be absent from the grid this year, stuck at the mercy of his gold driver grading. But, while he's not motivated by breaking start records, the French veteran is determined to return to the field next year.

WEC
Jul 24, 2021